Baby's First Christmas Gift Ideas: Keepsake Art Plush Toys They'll Treasure for Years

Baby Bebo, abstract art-inspired plush toy – a keepsake baby's first Christmas gift

A baby's first Christmas only happens once. The little one won't remember the wrapping paper (though they'll probably love chewing it), but the gifts you choose this year can become part of their story – the toy in the photos, the friend in the crib, the one they still keep on a shelf at sixteen.

That's why so many parents, grandparents and godparents look for a baby's first Christmas gift that feels a little more special than the usual. Here are our favorite keepsake ideas from the Modern-ici studio, where every plush character starts life as one of my paintings.

What Makes a Great Baby's First Christmas Gift?

Babies don't need much – which is exactly why a first Christmas gift is really about meaning. The best ones tend to be:

  • Keepsake-worthy – something that ages well and can be passed down or displayed.
  • Soft and huggable – a companion for naps, car rides and cozy mornings.
  • Beautiful to look at – because it will live in the nursery (and in every holiday photo) for years.
  • A little bit unique – not the same toy every other baby on the block receives.

Art-inspired plush toys check all four boxes: they're cuddly friends today and little pieces of art tomorrow.

Baby Bebo: The Perfect "First Friend"

If there's one plush made for a first Christmas, it's Baby Bebo ($47.99). With his abstract shapes and gentle expression, Bebo looks like he wandered straight out of a modern painting and into a crib. Tuck him under the tree with a handwritten note and the date – instant heirloom.

Luno Moon: For Dreamy Nights

New parents dream about one thing: sleep. Luno Moon ($47.99) is a surrealist art-inspired moon that makes a sweet bedtime companion and a lovely nursery accent. Pair it with a favorite goodnight book for a bedtime-themed first Christmas bundle.

Bunny Ibbo or Bear Fufo: Classic Animals, Modern Twist

Grandparents often love a traditional animal – a bunny or a bear – and that's wonderful. Our versions simply add a playful, artistic twist:

  • Bunny Ibbo ($47.99) – a surrealist bunny with whimsical proportions and lots of personality.
  • Bear Fufo ($47.99) – an abstract art-inspired teddy that feels both familiar and completely new.

Both are soft, huggable and photograph beautifully next to a little Christmas stocking.

Dog Sali: For the Family Dog's New Best Friend

Is there already a furry sibling at home? Dog Sali ($48.99), our sleepy surrealist puppy, is a charming way to celebrate baby's first Christmas with the family pup – and a cute prop for that "baby meets dog" holiday photo.

Go Big: My First Art Collection

For godparents, grandparents or anyone who wants to give something truly memorable, My First Art Collection (from $89.99) brings together several of our art-inspired characters in one bundle. Think of it as a baby's very first art collection – one they can grow up with, play with and, one day, display in their own home.

Make It a Keepsake Tradition

A few simple ideas to turn your gift into a memory:

  • Write a letter to the baby and tuck it in with the plush – read it together in ten years.
  • Take a yearly photo of your child with the same plush each Christmas and watch them grow next to it.
  • Add a nursery print – a dreamy piece like Requiem ($7 printable download) pairs beautifully with Luno Moon above the crib.

A Little Holiday Bonus

Shopping for more than one little one (or can't pick just one character)? Use code HOLIDAY20 for 20% off when you buy 2 or more plush toys – valid through December 31, 2026.

Find Their First Christmas Friend

A first Christmas gift doesn't have to be big – it just has to be loved. Every Modern-ici plush starts as an original painting and becomes a soft little piece of art made to be hugged. Browse the full Modern-ici collection and find the character who will join your baby's story this Christmas.

– Jitka